Rooted in Springfield. Focused on you.
About Elliott Insurance
Our Story
Elliott Insurance started with a simple idea. Insurance should be personal, dependable, and built around real people, not transactions.
That idea has guided us since 1933. Through changing markets, new risks, and decades of growth, our focus has stayed the same. Do right by the people who trust us, and build coverage that actually fits their lives.
We are an independent agency based in Springfield, Ohio. We work with a wide range of trusted carriers, which gives us the flexibility to find smarter solutions without being locked into a single option. While our reach has grown, our approach has not. We stay local, accessible, and invested in the communities we serve.
Our history matters, but not because of the number of years behind us. It matters because of the relationships built over time. First homes. New businesses. Growing families. Big transitions. Being part of those moments is what keeps our work meaningful.
Carrying The Legacy Forward
Elliott Insurance has never stood still. The world changes, risks evolve, and expectations grow. We have grown right along with it.
Today, the agency is led by Tim Elliott III, continuing a family legacy that began generations ago. While the tools, technology, and coverage options have changed, the core of the business has not. Take care of people. Do the work the right way. Be there when it matters.
Under Tim’s leadership, Elliott Insurance has expanded its reach, modernized how we serve clients, and invested in better systems to make insurance easier and more accessible. At the same time, the personal service that built this agency remains at the center of everything we do.
We respect where we came from, but we are focused on where we are going. The goal is not to protect a legacy for its own sake. The goal is to keep earning trust, one conversation and one client at a time.
Why Independence Matters
Insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all, and your needs don’t fit neatly into a template. That’s why being independent is so important. We aren’t tied to one company, which means we can compare plans across well-known carriers like Westfield, Auto-Owners, Grange, Safeco, Progressive, and more.
Instead of selling you what we have, we help you find what you need. Our team shops the market on your behalf, balancing cost, coverage, and service so you can feel confident you’re making the right choice today and as life evolves.
The industry’s leading insurance companies.
Choosing the right insurance can be complicated. We partner with the industry’s leading insurance companies so you can enjoy the most appropriate, affordable protection. Even better, we help you make the right choice.
Serving Springfield And Beyond
While Springfield will always be our home base, our reach extends across Ohio and into additional licensed states. We regularly serve clients in surrounding communities such as New Carlisle, Enon, Urbana, South Vienna, and South Charleston. This mix of local roots and multi-state capability allows us to support clients who are relocating, expanding their businesses, or managing properties in different regions.
Meet the Team
Insurance advisors who truly work for you
At Elliott Insurance, we believe the right coverage starts with the right people. Our team isn’t just here to sell policies, we’re here to listen, guide, and stand by you when life happens. Each of us brings unique experience and personality to the table, but we share one goal: protecting what matters most to you.
Rating
The Elliott Experience
What makes us different
Personal service with modern convenience.
Insurance should feel clear, convenient, and personal. That’s why we combine modern digital tools with the personal attention of a local team. Our approach blends the efficiency of a national provider with the neighborly service of a family-owned agency.
When you work with Elliott Insurance, you can expect proactive guidance, honest answers, and a relationship that lasts well beyond signing your policy.
Clarity
Simple, plain-English explanations of your options.
Choice
Access to multiple carriers so you get the best fit, not just the first offer.
Consistency
Regular check-ins to ensure your coverage grows with you.
Care
Advisors who treat you like family and advocate for you when you need it most.
Contact Us Today
Insurance questions? We’re here to help
Reach out anytime, call, click, or stop by.
Getting coverage should feel easy. Our team is available by phone, email, or in person at our Springfield office. Need a quote fast? Choose your path: Individual, Family, or Business Owner, and we’ll do the shopping for you, often with same-day follow-up. We’ll also be your advocate when it comes time to file a claim.